Showing posts with label high speed sync. Show all posts
Showing posts with label high speed sync. Show all posts

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Flash Series - Part 6: Use Flash in Daylight? Really?


I hear this exclamation a lot whenever I advise someone to use his flash as a fill light in strongly backlit situations, or when someone sees me using it in broad daylight. Despite being initially counter intuitive, this is perhaps the only practical use (image quality wise) of your built-in camera flash. Hit the jump for more explanation.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

How Sync Speed Multiplies Flash Power

I used to think a high sync speed was useful only for underexposing the ambient or eliminating it completely. However, even if you have no interest in totally killing ambient, a high sync speed can be useful for effectively multiplying your flash power.

A SIMPLE TEST

Here is a series of test shots to demonstrate this concept. (For these test shots, I used a Nikon D70 which has a "natural" sync speed of 1/500, which is twice as fast as the 1/250 sync speed of many other cameras.)

If you compare these two shots (with bounce flash), the overall exposure looks similar, and the flash/ambient balance is similar.



However, the second shot needed only half as much light from the flash, compared to the first shot, thanks to a higher sync speed.

First, to show the amount of ambient light, I took an all-ambient shot.  The exposure was ISO 200, f/2.8, 1/30.


I then took a baseline shot with bounce flash (TTL, with the flash pointed to camera rear right).  I set shutter speed to the usual sync speed of 1/250, and underexposed ambient by about 1 stop.  The resulting exposure was ISO 640, f/2.8, 1/250. TTL then added just enough flash to result in a normal exposure (not underexposure).

I took another test shot, this time using a higher sync speed of 1/500.  Again underexposing ambient by 1 stop, the resulting exposure was ISO 1600, f/2.8, 1/500.  TTL again added enough flash to result in a normal exposure (not underexposure).

Comparing the exposure of the baseline shot with the test shot, the flash had to work about twice as hard in the first shot (ISO 640, f/2.8) as in the second shot (ISO 1600, f/2.8).  Thus, we were able to use a high sync speed not to underexpose the ambient, but to get a higher effective flash range.

WHAT ABOUT HIGH SPEED SYNC?
If being able to sync at high shutter speeds effectively increases flash power, what about using high speed sync?  Recap: above a camera's sync speed, cameras with mechanical shutters use the front curtain and rear curtain to form a slit that travels across the sensor.  See this slow-motion video of a shutter at 1/1000 speed:

At these speeeds, the sensor is never fully exposed at any given time, therefore if we use a flash, the flash would be partially blocked by the rear curtain, visible as a black bar across the frame.

High speed sync gets around the sync speed limitation by emitting many bursts of flash over the entire time period that the sensor is exposed by the moving slit.

The problem with HSS is that it weakens your flash by at least 2 stops compared to using a neutral density filter.  Moreover, the higher your shutter speed, the weaker the flash gets.

For my D300 (with a 1/250 natural sync speed), the indicated range of an SB-800 at ISO 200, f/2.8 is 20 meters at a shutter speed of 1/250 or slower.  At 1/500 (1 stop faster), the range drops to 9.5 meters (a reduction of more than 2 stops). 
At 1/1000, the range is 6.7m.
At 1/2000, the range is 4.8m.
At 1/4000, the range is 3.4m.
At 1/8000, the range is 2.4m.
In other words, any gain in flash efficiency from the use of a higher shutter speed is more than offset by the HSS penalty.  HSS is a losing proposition in terms of power and efficiency, and it's not a substitute for a higher natural sync speed.

RELATED POSTS

Monday, November 1, 2010

The most efficient setting for bounce flash

Suppose you have a super camera that had no ISO limit - it could give you a noiseless image even at 1 billion ISO.  With such a camera, would you be able to use bounce flash anywhere? 

Not necessarily. When using bounce flash, the aperture and ISO combination must indeed allow enough light from the flash to reach the sensor, and of course unlimited ISO would help. However, the other limit is that the flash must be at least as bright as 1/8 of the ambient exposure (i.e. 3 stops below ambient). Otherwise, the flash exposure would not be noticeable.

In the hypothetical example of our super camera, even having infinite ISO does not mean you can bounce anywhere you want. If for example it's mid-afternoon on a bright sunny-16 day, you cannot bounce a flash from a wall that's 20 feet away no matter what ISO (or aperture) you choose because the flash would then be negligible compared to the ambient light.

What's the relevance of this to everyday shooting? What this means is that when we're bouncing while there is ample ambient light, we should start by selecting the sync speed to minimize the ratio of ambient light relative to the flash. We then choose a reasonably "bright" ISO and aperture combination to allow the bounce flash to show up in the image, *so long as the shutter doesn't go above sync speed*. If we choose an aperture so wide and/or an ISO so high that shutter is higher than sync speed, then our flash will be forced to use high speed sync, which causes the loss of around 2 stops of power.  This is why we shouldn't automatically choose a wide aperture and high ISO when bouncing (unless ambient is dim).

What if ambient is so bright that even at sync speed, the aperture is narrow and/or ISO is low? That means it's quite possibly beyond the power of our flash to bounce under the circumstances. Increasing ISO or widening the aperture under such circumstances does not help the image - it only leads to overexposure of ambient. The aperture and ISO combo at sync speed for ambient (with at least slight underexposure) is a non-negotiable limit. If my flash can't bounce at those settings, then no amount of adjusting the aperture and ISO can fix the problem. 

That's the mistake I made with the shot below. I selected ISO 800 as a typical minimum ISO for bouncing, and selected a wide aperture (f/2.8). Although I selected sync speed, the point I missed at that time, is that having a high ISO and wide aperture were not helping in those circumstances.


When I saw the overexposure on the LCD screen, I switched to aperture priority as a quick way of getting a ballpark exposure (I knew the kids wouldn't stay put).  What I didn't notice was that because I was using f/2.8 and ISO 200, the camera was giving me a shutter speed of 1/2000, well into high speed sync territory.  With high speed sync plus bounce flash, I couldn't hope to get enough light on the kids:

The best I could do was to try to salvage the image in post, which is never as good as getting it right in the first place.

Post-processing is not a panacea.  For example, this one was had unrecoverable details from completely blown highlights (even though I was using raw).

I should have just realized I was asking too much from the flash and either used an umbrella instead or doubled up with the YN-560 plus SB-800 (which would let me gain only 1 stop more light).  Fortunately some shots did turn out OK:


For future reference, I tried to test what was the "darkest" aperture and ISO combo setting I could use with an 8 foot white ceiling, sb800 on full zoom 105mm aimed straight up, and at full power. I got around f/14 @ ISO 200 (i.e., equivalent to f/10 @ ISO 100) with the flash bright enough to act as key light, with the subject around 8 feet away.

Friday, July 30, 2010

Nikon CLS Advanced Wireless Lighting Tip: Wireless High Speed Sync (Basic)


(f/2.8, 1/1000, ISO 100, Nikon D80, Tamron 28-75 f/2.8)


One of the strengths of Nikon's system is its advanced wireless lighting (AWL) which allows a commander-capable flash to remotely control and adjust compatible slave flashes.  Other systems have remote flash capability as well to varying degrees.  However, not all flash systems can do wireless high speed sync (HSS) but Nikon's AWL can.

A lot of people (myself included) use the popup flash as a commander, with an external flash such as an SB-600, SB-800, or SB-900 as a slave.  By default, the commander mode menu is set to allow the popup flash to contribute to the exposure (specifically, the default for the popup flash is TTL with 0 FEC).  The problem is that the popup flash does not have high speed sync.  What happens then is that when the popup flash is set to contribute to the exposure, the shutter speed is limited to the sync speed (e.g. 1/250).

In order to use wireless HSS, use the commander menu to deactivate the popup flash (set it to "--"), meaning it will only be used as a commander and will not contribute to the exposure.  If you want to use the commander to contribute to the exposure (e.g., as fill), then use an HSS-capable commander flash (SB-800 or SB-900).

Wednesday, July 21, 2010

Why is sync speed optimal for flash efficiency? (Basic)

When using flash, shooting at the sync speed ensures that you're using your flash most efficiently. Here's why.

Aperture affects both ambient and flash exposure. The larger the aperture, the more light enters the sensor (from both flash and ambient). The most output from your flash will result from the widest aperture. The catch though is that a wider aperture will also increase the ambient exposure, possibly to the point of overexposure.

Enter shutter speed. Shutter speed affects ambient but not flash exposure (up to a limit, as discussed below). The duration of a burst of flash is so brief that whether the shutter travels quickly or slowly, all of the flash burst reaches the sensor. That is, of course, assuming the entire sensor is exposed.

Indeed, the entire sensor is fully exposed at typical shutter speeds. At a high shutter speed, however, the rear curtain starts to close even before the front curtain has traveled completely, therefore the sensor is never fully exposed at any given time. When the flash is fired at these very high speeds, the part that is covered by the rear curtain will not be exposed to flash, leading to uneven exposure which is visible as a dark bar across the bottom or top of the image. The highest shutter speed where the entire sensor is fully exposed is the camera's sync speed. Typical sync speeds are 1/200 or 1/250, but sometimes as slow as 1/125 and as high as 1/500. (Trivia: medium format cameras with leaf shutter lenses can sync at all speeds, and point-and-shoots can sync at any speed because they don't have mechanical shutters :-D ) By default, cameras usually prevent the use of shutter speeds faster than the sync speed when the flash is being used.

Going back to the discussion, higher shutter speeds will nonetheless reduce ambient exposure. We use this to our advantage using the reciprocal relationship between shutter speed and aperture for any given exposure. Let's say it's a bright, sunny day, and the correct exposure is f/16 at 1/125 at 100 ISO. Under the reciprocity principle, you can get the same exposure with any of these combinations:

f/11 at 1/250 at 100 ISO
f/16 at 1/125 at 100 ISO
f/22 at 1/60 at 100 ISO

Of the three combinations above, the one that will require the least power from the flash is the one with the widest aperture, i.e., f/11 at 1/250 at 100 ISO.

Does that mean we should just use aperture priority and always choose the widest aperture to get the most from our flash? Not necessarily. If conditions are bright and aperture is wide, then the shutter speed can be pretty high -- higher than the sync speed. In the example above, suppose we had a lens that can go as wide as f/2.8. If we change aperture to f/2.8, the shutter speed for the same exposure would be 1/4000, which is way faster than the sync speed.

What about high speed sync mode? External flashes can fire at shutter speeds higher than the natural sync speed at the expense of output by firing many small flash bursts (instead of a single flash burst) while the rear curtain travels across the sensor. With HSS, however, the flash loses slightly more than 2 stops of output. In other words, it becomes more than 4x weaker. In other words, its range drops to slightly less than half. You get the idea.

In summary, if you want to maximize your flash while minimizing your ambient, shoot at the sync speed.