Last Sunday, we went to Santa Monica's Pacific Park, a small amusement park at the famous Santa Monica pier. I took some shots Strobist-style (i.e. with off-camera flash). In this post, I would like to share some samples comparing on-camera flash, off-camera flash, and no flash.
Techniques, Tools, Resources, Real World Gear Reviews and Flash Tutorials for taking better candid and family photos.
Showing posts with label manual. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manual. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 26, 2015
Strobist Sunday at Santa Monica with the Stylus 1
Last Sunday, we went to Santa Monica's Pacific Park, a small amusement park at the famous Santa Monica pier. I took some shots Strobist-style (i.e. with off-camera flash). In this post, I would like to share some samples comparing on-camera flash, off-camera flash, and no flash.
Tuesday, August 11, 2015
True or False? "Aperture Controls Flash, Shutter Speed Controls Ambient"
One of the often-repeated rules of thumb for flash is that "aperture controls flash, while shutter speed controls ambient." In this post, we'll see why this adage can be misleading.
Sunday, July 12, 2015
Spectacular Strobe Sale: Godox Ving V850 and V860
The Godox Ving is a unique speedlight that uses rechargeable Lithium batteries instead of AA batteries. As a result, you get a far greater battery life (650 full power flashes -- claimed to be the equivalent of 12 AA batteries), and you have faster recycling times. It's almost like having an external battery pack, but built-in to the speedlight itself! Check out this demo video by Gadget Infinity:
The Ving currently has three variants: the V850 is a manual flash, while the V860N is for Nikon i-TTL and the V860C is for Canon E-TTL. Godox has its own wireless radio system: the FT-16, which can adjust flashes remotely, and which is compatible with the Ving and several other Godox products, such as the Witstro and their extensive monolight lineup.
The Ving has received positive reviews from Fstoppers (reviewing the rebranded Neewer TT850), Flash Havoc, Lighting Rumors and others.
SALE
The good news is the Godox Ving is on sale: buy 1, get the 2nd at 50% off, through eBay seller "zeniko_online_store":
This sale applies only to Zeniko's U.S. eBay stores (they have items listed from their stores in China, which have a lower price per unit but aren't included in the sale). To avail of the discount, just select "2" under quantity. The price will be updated automatically.
Note: I'm not affiliated with Zeniko or eBay, and we receive no commissions on this. I'm just passing along this tip!
The Ving currently has three variants: the V850 is a manual flash, while the V860N is for Nikon i-TTL and the V860C is for Canon E-TTL. Godox has its own wireless radio system: the FT-16, which can adjust flashes remotely, and which is compatible with the Ving and several other Godox products, such as the Witstro and their extensive monolight lineup.
The Ving has received positive reviews from Fstoppers (reviewing the rebranded Neewer TT850), Flash Havoc, Lighting Rumors and others.
SALE
The good news is the Godox Ving is on sale: buy 1, get the 2nd at 50% off, through eBay seller "zeniko_online_store":
This sale applies only to Zeniko's U.S. eBay stores (they have items listed from their stores in China, which have a lower price per unit but aren't included in the sale). To avail of the discount, just select "2" under quantity. The price will be updated automatically.
Note: I'm not affiliated with Zeniko or eBay, and we receive no commissions on this. I'm just passing along this tip!
Monday, October 22, 2012
Better Point-and-Shoot Shots with an External Flash
Last weekend, one of our friends celebrated their daughter's birthday party. On this kind of occasion, I don't usually bring a DSLR anymore - I feel it is a little too much when we're not the celebrants. Instead, I brought our trusty Lumix LX5 (reviewed here). However, to get the best image quality out of the LX5, I paired it with an external flash, the Yongnuo YN-560EX (reviewed here).
Yes, the 560EX is a manual not TTL flash. (I don't have a dedicated TTL flash for the Lumix LX5.) However, using a manual flash while shooting run-and-gun is actually easier than it sounds. (See: Therapy for TTL Addiction: How to Use Manual Flash).
In this post, I'll discuss my thought process in setting the flash and ambient exposures.
Monday, October 25, 2010
Selling Staid Stuff Sexily in Sizzling Strobist Style - Part 2 (Basic)
One thing I noticed about stores in malls is that higher end ones tend to use a lot of hard light sources and they try to use spotlights to create pools of light. I tried to use that approach for the shot above.
My wife was bugging me to sell my golf clubs. I didn't argue even a bit. I hadn't touched these clubs in a very long while, and I'm terrible at golf anyway. Once, my friend and I were at the driving range and I hit the ball with my driver so badly that the ball flew perpendicularly from the intended path and hit my friend's leg. If you think that was bad, it happened yet again on another occasion, hitting another friend's butt that time.
Back to the topic...
The sky was overcast, and I could have taken a shot with just ambient light, and the light would have looked very soft like this:
Instead, to add a bit of spice, I decided to create a subtle spotlight. To avoid a harsh look, however, the ratio between the highlight and the shadow would have to be low. The shadowless ambient light was perfect for providing fill. I just underexposed ambient by about a stop.
For the spotlight, I put a flash on a tripod on camera right (the SB-800 was attached to the AS-19
Hopefully I can sell these clubs soon to avoid hurting more people.
Some related posts:
- Selling Staid Stuff Sexily in Sizzling Strobist Style - Part 1
- TTL vs. Manual: False Dilemma
- Therapy for TTL Addiction: How to Use Manual Flash
- Quality vs. Contrast
- Check out this very good explanation of Fill Light from www.portraitlighting.net
Friday, October 1, 2010
Super Manual Flash
David Hobby (Strobist.com) recently posted an interesting tip for manual flash users that will allow the camera to track the ambient exposure automatically, even with variable ambient light conditions: http://strobist.blogspot.com/2010/10/how-to-track-ambient-automatically.html . Clearly, there's some benefit from not having to keep adjusting flash or ambient exposure as conditions change. Taking that a step further, wouldn't it be cool if you've setup the shot and have nailed the flash and ambient exposure, and the flash was smart enough to adjust power automatically to maintain that flash exposure even if you reposition your lights or adjust your exposure? OK you saw this coming... I'm talking of course about TTL flash.
If you're a manual-only flash user, and you do any photography other than setup shots, I really would strongly recommend adding TTL flash to your repertoire. The great thing is, if you already know manual flash, you already have a leg up.
BUT TTL IS SO UNPREDICTABLE AND INCONSISTENT
Common criticisms by manual flash users about TTL flash include unpredictability and variability:
- Unpredictable in that "you never know what you're gonna get".
- Variable in that TTL uses the reflection from preflashes to guess the correct flash exposure and is thus subject to reflection-based metering weaknesses. For example, even though aperture, ISO, flash-to-subject distance, and the flash's guide number are held constant, flash exposure can vary depending on the reflectance of the image in the frame (which in turn can vary based on the reflectance of the subject or other elements).
OK, guilty as charged on both counts. In theory, you never know with 100% certainty what flash exposure you're going to get with TTL until you take at least that first test shot. In reality though, TTL gets reasonably close to an ok flash exposure. This is not that much different from using manual flash without a flashmeter or calculator (for GN calculations). The difference is that instead of you guessing the amount of power you need, the camera and flash offer a ballpark estimate. If you don't like the flash exposure you get, you simply adjust with flash exposure compensation - the same way you would adjust your power upward or downward if you didn't like the flash exposure you got with your test shot on manual flash mode.
It's also true that TTL can be variable even under conditions when flash exposure should be constant. Fortunately, if this theoretical variability is truly a dealbreaker for you, there are a few answers for that.
1. For Canon, Nikon and Olympus:
Spot meter a gray card when you take the shot. TTL will set flash exposure to render that gray card as middle gray (within the flash's power limits). This will work even in conditions that would normally fool TTL such as including a highly reflective object in the shot. Adjust flash exposure upward or downward if you wish using flash exposure compensation. Then use FV lock (aka FEL or FV Flash Lock) to lock the desired flash exposure. You will get the same flash exposure consistency that you will get from manual.
2. For Sony, Pentax, and other cameras that don't have FV Lock:
Include a gray card in your test shot, and adjust TTL flash exposure (with flash exposure compensation) to render the gray card as gray. When you do this, don't spot meter from the gray card because if you remove the gray card then the flash exposure will change. Just use the gray card in the frame as a guide for an "accurate" flash exposure.
In real life, TTL shooters don't use a gray card because we just use FEC to adjust whenever we don't like the flash exposure. Plus, most of the time (at least for me), the flash exposure doesn't really vary all that much anyway (except in unusual cases).
Ready to give TTL a try? Don't worry - it doesn't bite. :)
HOW TO USE TTL FLASH:
1. Set the ambient exposure as you would with manual flash.
2. Take a test shot with TTL flash.
3. Estimate the flash over- or underexposure and adjust the TTL flash accordingly, using flash exposure compensation.
4. Feel free to change shutter OR aperture OR ISO OR subject-to-flash distance OR any combination of the above. You can even change modifiers or filters or gels. TTL will keep the flash exposure the same!
It may help to think of TTL flash as a smart manual flash that can give you a reasonable guess of the right amount of power automatically upfront (which you can adjust), and also adjusts power automatically to keep your flash exposure the same from shot-to-shot, except that it isn't perfect so it needs tweaking upward or downward.
And if you're a TTL-only user reading this, check out these related posts:
TTL vs. Manual: a False Dilemma http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/09/ttl-vs-manual-flash-false-dilemma.html
Therapy for TTL Addiction http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/09/therapy-for-ttl-addiction-how-to-use.html
If you're a manual-only flash user, and you do any photography other than setup shots, I really would strongly recommend adding TTL flash to your repertoire. The great thing is, if you already know manual flash, you already have a leg up.
BUT TTL IS SO UNPREDICTABLE AND INCONSISTENT
Common criticisms by manual flash users about TTL flash include unpredictability and variability:
- Unpredictable in that "you never know what you're gonna get".
- Variable in that TTL uses the reflection from preflashes to guess the correct flash exposure and is thus subject to reflection-based metering weaknesses. For example, even though aperture, ISO, flash-to-subject distance, and the flash's guide number are held constant, flash exposure can vary depending on the reflectance of the image in the frame (which in turn can vary based on the reflectance of the subject or other elements).
OK, guilty as charged on both counts. In theory, you never know with 100% certainty what flash exposure you're going to get with TTL until you take at least that first test shot. In reality though, TTL gets reasonably close to an ok flash exposure. This is not that much different from using manual flash without a flashmeter or calculator (for GN calculations). The difference is that instead of you guessing the amount of power you need, the camera and flash offer a ballpark estimate. If you don't like the flash exposure you get, you simply adjust with flash exposure compensation - the same way you would adjust your power upward or downward if you didn't like the flash exposure you got with your test shot on manual flash mode.
It's also true that TTL can be variable even under conditions when flash exposure should be constant. Fortunately, if this theoretical variability is truly a dealbreaker for you, there are a few answers for that.
1. For Canon, Nikon and Olympus:
Spot meter a gray card when you take the shot. TTL will set flash exposure to render that gray card as middle gray (within the flash's power limits). This will work even in conditions that would normally fool TTL such as including a highly reflective object in the shot. Adjust flash exposure upward or downward if you wish using flash exposure compensation. Then use FV lock (aka FEL or FV Flash Lock) to lock the desired flash exposure. You will get the same flash exposure consistency that you will get from manual.
2. For Sony, Pentax, and other cameras that don't have FV Lock:
Include a gray card in your test shot, and adjust TTL flash exposure (with flash exposure compensation) to render the gray card as gray. When you do this, don't spot meter from the gray card because if you remove the gray card then the flash exposure will change. Just use the gray card in the frame as a guide for an "accurate" flash exposure.
In real life, TTL shooters don't use a gray card because we just use FEC to adjust whenever we don't like the flash exposure. Plus, most of the time (at least for me), the flash exposure doesn't really vary all that much anyway (except in unusual cases).
Ready to give TTL a try? Don't worry - it doesn't bite. :)
HOW TO USE TTL FLASH:
1. Set the ambient exposure as you would with manual flash.
2. Take a test shot with TTL flash.
3. Estimate the flash over- or underexposure and adjust the TTL flash accordingly, using flash exposure compensation.
4. Feel free to change shutter OR aperture OR ISO OR subject-to-flash distance OR any combination of the above. You can even change modifiers or filters or gels. TTL will keep the flash exposure the same!
It may help to think of TTL flash as a smart manual flash that can give you a reasonable guess of the right amount of power automatically upfront (which you can adjust), and also adjusts power automatically to keep your flash exposure the same from shot-to-shot, except that it isn't perfect so it needs tweaking upward or downward.
And if you're a TTL-only user reading this, check out these related posts:
TTL vs. Manual: a False Dilemma http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/09/ttl-vs-manual-flash-false-dilemma.html
Therapy for TTL Addiction http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/09/therapy-for-ttl-addiction-how-to-use.html
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Therapy for TTL Addiction: How to Use Manual Flash
Sure, you're a TTL expert but are you dependent on TTL? If your trusty SB-800 or 580EXII or whatever suddenly failed and all you had was a manual flash, would you be comfortable using it? I was a TTL addict but as I did more setup shots, I "saw the light" and became an advocate of learning both TTL and manual flash. See related post: http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/09/ttl-vs-manual-flash-false-dilemma.html . This is a follow-up post for TTL-only users on how to learn and use manual flash. Don't worry, it's not as hard as it looks.

QUICK REVIEW OF MANUAL VS. TTL FLASH
With TTL, the camera guesses the flash exposure, then controls the flash output automatically to match that flash exposure. With manual, you control the amount of flash output to get the flash exposure you want.
BENEFITS OF LEARNING MANUAL FLASH
1. For setup shots, manual flash GUARANTEES predictability and repeatability. If the flash to subject distance doesn't change from shot-to-shot, and the aperture and ISO don't change, then the 'correct' flash exposure shouldn't change either, right? With TTL, the flash exposure may change if you change your composition and sometimes your colors (by zooming in, changing the subject's clothing, adding or changing the subject etc. etc.) even though the correct flash exposure shouldn't have changed. With manual flash, that variability is never going to be an issue. You always know what you're going to get.
2. With manual flash, I'm forced to pre-visualize the correct flash exposure. With TTL flash, there's always the temptation to accept the camera's guess of flash exposure because the truth is, with TTL, the flash exposure looks ok (from at least some point of view) most of the time. It's convenient but also easy to be lazy, instead of actively thinking about tone placement and the "look" that we want.
3. Awareness. If you only use TTL flash, you never know how much power the flash is using. Knowing the amount of power is useful to know how much more light is available if you want to use a smaller aperture or lower ISO. It's also useful for getting an idea of how much battery life you're using up (for some reason the SB800 and SB900 don't have battery life indicators).
4. Manual flash offers more bang for the buck. Manual flash is much cheaper than TTL in terms of the flashes themselves and the triggering options. Example of a wireless setup:
SB600 = $220. (If you don't have a commander-capable popup flash, add SU-800 commander $255.)
vs.
YN560 ($85) + RF-602 radio trigger transmitter and receiver ($30 on ebay) = $115. The incremental cost of adding additional flashes and receivers will be less (you only need one transmitter).
This is why I got a manual flash for my second flash (although I would have gotten an SB600 if I had extra money).
5. Sole control. With manual flash, you take out the camera's algorithms out of the equation. If the flash exposure sucks - it's your fault. If the flash exposure rocks - you da man.
6. Manual flash is usable with cameras that don't have hotshoes. Just get a manual flash with a built-in digital slave and you're good to go.
HOW TO USE MANUAL FLASH
The textbook way to use manual flash is to use a flashmeter. Another way is to estimate the distance from subject-to-flash and use the guide number equation. In reality, a number of manual flash users do without a flashmeter or calculator, and use trial-and-error intelligently.
Here's how I use manual flash:
1. I visualize the flash exposure.
2. I set the ISO, aperture and shutter speed for the conditions (underexposing if necessary). I may take a test shot (without flash) to confirm.
3. I set my best guess of manual flash power based on the ISO, aperture, and how I'm using the flash. If I'm using bare flash directly, then I will likely pick a low power like 1/64 or 1/32. If I'm using bounce flash, I will likely pick high power like full power or 1/2.
4. I take a test shot and check the result on the LCD and the histogram. (Note: the vertical lines on the histogram aren't totally random. They're about 1 stop apart.)
5. Based on the results, I estimate the amount of flash over- or underexposure in stops and adjust the manual flash power accordingly. If I want partial stops, I move the flash closer or further, and/or adjust aperture or ISO.
With this procedure, I usually get the flash exposure I want within 2 or 3 test shots. Here's a tip on how to get better at estimating flash over- or underexposure: use raw and learn postprocessing. When you postprocess as part of your regular workflow, you adjust exposure so often that you become better at estimating over- and underexposure. :) Oh, btw, plug in the exposure adjustment instead of using the slider.
This procedure is not as tedious as it may sound. Just think of it as really crummy TTL :)). With TTL we adjust the default flash exposure (0 FEC) based on the result we want. This is kind of like that, except that the default flash exposure may be way off.
Samples:
I used the above procedure for the shot at the top. A couple more sample shots using the same procedure:

Blogged here: http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/08/real-estate-photos-part-1-strobist.html

Blogged here: http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/07/selling-stuff-sexily-strobist-style.html
If you're a manual-only flash user, check out this related post: Super Manual Flash

QUICK REVIEW OF MANUAL VS. TTL FLASH
With TTL, the camera guesses the flash exposure, then controls the flash output automatically to match that flash exposure. With manual, you control the amount of flash output to get the flash exposure you want.
BENEFITS OF LEARNING MANUAL FLASH
1. For setup shots, manual flash GUARANTEES predictability and repeatability. If the flash to subject distance doesn't change from shot-to-shot, and the aperture and ISO don't change, then the 'correct' flash exposure shouldn't change either, right? With TTL, the flash exposure may change if you change your composition and sometimes your colors (by zooming in, changing the subject's clothing, adding or changing the subject etc. etc.) even though the correct flash exposure shouldn't have changed. With manual flash, that variability is never going to be an issue. You always know what you're going to get.
2. With manual flash, I'm forced to pre-visualize the correct flash exposure. With TTL flash, there's always the temptation to accept the camera's guess of flash exposure because the truth is, with TTL, the flash exposure looks ok (from at least some point of view) most of the time. It's convenient but also easy to be lazy, instead of actively thinking about tone placement and the "look" that we want.
3. Awareness. If you only use TTL flash, you never know how much power the flash is using. Knowing the amount of power is useful to know how much more light is available if you want to use a smaller aperture or lower ISO. It's also useful for getting an idea of how much battery life you're using up (for some reason the SB800 and SB900 don't have battery life indicators).
4. Manual flash offers more bang for the buck. Manual flash is much cheaper than TTL in terms of the flashes themselves and the triggering options. Example of a wireless setup:
SB600 = $220. (If you don't have a commander-capable popup flash, add SU-800 commander $255.)
vs.
YN560 ($85) + RF-602 radio trigger transmitter and receiver ($30 on ebay) = $115. The incremental cost of adding additional flashes and receivers will be less (you only need one transmitter).
This is why I got a manual flash for my second flash (although I would have gotten an SB600 if I had extra money).
5. Sole control. With manual flash, you take out the camera's algorithms out of the equation. If the flash exposure sucks - it's your fault. If the flash exposure rocks - you da man.
6. Manual flash is usable with cameras that don't have hotshoes. Just get a manual flash with a built-in digital slave and you're good to go.
HOW TO USE MANUAL FLASH
The textbook way to use manual flash is to use a flashmeter. Another way is to estimate the distance from subject-to-flash and use the guide number equation. In reality, a number of manual flash users do without a flashmeter or calculator, and use trial-and-error intelligently.
Here's how I use manual flash:
1. I visualize the flash exposure.
2. I set the ISO, aperture and shutter speed for the conditions (underexposing if necessary). I may take a test shot (without flash) to confirm.
3. I set my best guess of manual flash power based on the ISO, aperture, and how I'm using the flash. If I'm using bare flash directly, then I will likely pick a low power like 1/64 or 1/32. If I'm using bounce flash, I will likely pick high power like full power or 1/2.
4. I take a test shot and check the result on the LCD and the histogram. (Note: the vertical lines on the histogram aren't totally random. They're about 1 stop apart.)
5. Based on the results, I estimate the amount of flash over- or underexposure in stops and adjust the manual flash power accordingly. If I want partial stops, I move the flash closer or further, and/or adjust aperture or ISO.
With this procedure, I usually get the flash exposure I want within 2 or 3 test shots. Here's a tip on how to get better at estimating flash over- or underexposure: use raw and learn postprocessing. When you postprocess as part of your regular workflow, you adjust exposure so often that you become better at estimating over- and underexposure. :) Oh, btw, plug in the exposure adjustment instead of using the slider.
This procedure is not as tedious as it may sound. Just think of it as really crummy TTL :)). With TTL we adjust the default flash exposure (0 FEC) based on the result we want. This is kind of like that, except that the default flash exposure may be way off.
Samples:
I used the above procedure for the shot at the top. A couple more sample shots using the same procedure:

Blogged here: http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/08/real-estate-photos-part-1-strobist.html
Blogged here: http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2010/07/selling-stuff-sexily-strobist-style.html
If you're a manual-only flash user, check out this related post: Super Manual Flash
Tuesday, September 14, 2010
TTL vs. Manual Flash: A False Dilemma
Among flash users, there has been a rift between manual flash proponents and TTL flash advocates, with some proponents of one declaring their method superior to the other.
MANUAL VS. TTL: WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE
Manual flash means the user sets the power output himself in order to get the desired amount of flash recorded in the picture (i.e., flash exposure). The flash exposure is affected by the available power of the flash (its guide number), the aperture, the ISO, and the distance of the flash to the subject.
With TTL flash, the camera and flash set the output automatically in order to achieve a more or less _constant_ flash exposure (with almost any combination of guide number, aperture, ISO, or flash-to-subject distance), analogous to your P, A, or S modes trying to achieve a middle grey, which the user then adjusts to his or her liking using exposure compensation. With flash, the equivalent control is flash exposure compensation (FEC).
THE CONTROVERSY AND THE MYTH
Some manual flash users scoff at TTL. One of the nicknames for TTL in manual flash circles is "idiot mode." I think that reputation among some manual flash users is ironically based on ignorance about how TTL is controlled. It is true that TTL may be left to operate automatically, and no doubt the majority of TTL users do exactly that (assuming we include point-and-shoot cameras). Perhaps it is from that phenomenon that TTL gained a reputation for being completely automatic like the green mode on some cameras. However, I would wager that any person that calls TTL "idiot mode" does not really know how to control TTL. (Specifically, I doubt any such person would pass Lesson 11 of the TTL Flash Tutorial.)
Serious TTL users advocate adjusting TTL through flash exposure compensation, in addition to minding other lighting fundamentals such as balancing flash and ambient.
TTL CONTROL
A myth about TTL is that it doesn't offer as much "control" as manual flash. With respect to range there is an element of truth to that. With a good manual flash, you can choose any setting from full power to 1/128 power, a range of 7 stops (though some units have a range less than that). Pretty amazing control huh?
Well here's the thing: on my TTL flash, I can go anywhere from -3 FEC to +3 FEC, in 1/3 stop increments. A range of 6 stops. Not bad for an idiot mode. If I use cumulative FEC adjustments (meaning I make an adjustment on the camera's FEC button and the flash's FEC button), the range expands to -6 FEC to +4 FEC. A range of 10 stops. Moreover, a flash on TTL can go below 1/128 power, without any neutral density gels or workarounds.
The partial-stop increments are not to be ignored. Some flash units with manual flash can be adjusted in 1/3 stop increments, such as the SB-800 (indeed, the manual YN-560 flash can be adjusted in 1/8 stop increments). However, not all manual flash are capable of partial-stop increments between full power and minimum power. For those manual flash units, users adjust the distance between the flash and subject, alter the aperture or ISO, or use a neutral density gel to adjust the flash output in smaller increments.
THE CATCH
The catch with TTL is that the 0 FEC point is determined by the camera and flash, and as TTL becomes more advanced, the way that flash exposure determined becomes more complicated to understand. On the other hand, it's very unlikely that the camera and flash can be 6 stops away from the 'right'amount of flash.
The other complaint against TTL is consistency. With TTL, it is theoretically possible for the flash exposure to vary from shot to shot when the composition or zoom varies. If the ambient light, aperture, ISO, subject-to-flash distance, and the guide number of the flash do not change, then manual flash users point out that the flash exposure should also be consistent. In practice though, I haven't seen a huge variation shot-to-shot under conditions when flash exposure is supposed to be constant. In addition, in some cameras, there are tools such as FV lock (flash value lock -- analogous to auto exposure lock) that can lock the flash exposure for consistency.
IS TTL FLASH SUPERIOR TO MANUAL FLASH?
Short answer: in my opinion, no. Just as no single exposure mode (P, A, S, M) is superior in every situation, neither do I believe that TTL or manual will be superior to the other in all circumstances.
TTL is quicker in fast-changing shooting conditions (e.g. weddings) when ambient light varies constantly and subject to flash distance can vary greatly (especially if bouncing the flash). In such conditions, it is difficult to get the keep adjusting flash output with manual flash with each small change to maintain the result we want.
On the other hand, in setup shots where the flash is on a stand and won't be moving, and the subject will stay in the same place for the shots, using manual would guarantee control and consistency from shot to shot. There are also situations where we are pushing the flash to the limits of its power and we know in advance that we want to use full power -- it would make sense to switch to manual flash. Finally, there are rare occasions when TTL will simply fail for reasons that are not immediately apparent. In such cases, it would be great to know that you can always switch to manual.
Unless you take only one type of photo, I believe it makes sense to learn and be comfortable with both TTL and manual flash. I must confess I often use TTL (because most of my shots are candid) but I can switch to manual when needed. The shot at the beginning of this article was taken on an occasion when I was switching from one to the other, and sometimes combining both. Link to album. I doubt that you can tell which shot was shot with which method. :)
WHICH TO LEARN FIRST
You can learn either one first, but I believe you can get more-or-less ok results faster with TTL flash. I analogize again to the P, A, and S modes. Many beginners, instead of jumping to manual exposure mode, start out on those semi-automatic modes which frees them to think of composition and other aspects of the photo. However, there are photogs who do believe you learn faster with manual flash. It's up to you!
If you shoot with manual flash only or TTL flash only, I suggest you give the other flash method a shot. You can only gain from it.
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Tip: Shutter + Aperture Priority for Nikon (Intermediate)
Some Pentax DSLRs have a nifty exposure mode called Shutter and Aperture Priority (TAv), which allows you to dial in the aperture you want, the shutter speed you want, then let the camera pick the ISO automatically. This is useful if for example you have a specific aperture and shutter speed combination that you want.
At least some Nikon cameras can emulate that TAv function to some extent. Here's how:
1. Switch to manual exposure mode.
2. Turn on Auto ISO.
3. Dial in the aperture and shutter speed that you want.
You'll notice that Auto ISO will adjust your exposure upward or downward, up to as low as the base ISO to as high as the ISO limit that you set in the menus. You'll also notice that the light meter won't move as it usually does, instead showing 0 until you go beyond the minimum or maximum ISO. If you do want to adjust exposure to match your intent, you can use exposure compensation.
Here are test shots. The baseline shot is at ISO 800, f/4, 1/25, taken on manual exposure mode, matrix metering, with the light meter at 0. Let's assume that this is the correct exposure.
In the next shot, I activated Auto ISO, then changed the aperture and shutter to f/5.6, 1/50, with ISO initially at 800. ISO automatically adjusted to 2800, showing that Auto ISO will adjust upward as needed.
In the following shot, I changed the aperture and shutter to f/2.8, 1/13 with ISO initially at 800. ISO automatically adjusted to 220, showing that Auto ISO will also adjust downward as needed.
In this shot, I changed the aperture and shutter to f/2.8, 1/6. ISO could not adjust below the base ISO (ISO 200 for the D300), resulting in overexposure (you do get a warning of sorts because the light meter will show an overexposure).
At least some Nikon cameras can emulate that TAv function to some extent. Here's how:
1. Switch to manual exposure mode.
2. Turn on Auto ISO.
3. Dial in the aperture and shutter speed that you want.
You'll notice that Auto ISO will adjust your exposure upward or downward, up to as low as the base ISO to as high as the ISO limit that you set in the menus. You'll also notice that the light meter won't move as it usually does, instead showing 0 until you go beyond the minimum or maximum ISO. If you do want to adjust exposure to match your intent, you can use exposure compensation.
Here are test shots. The baseline shot is at ISO 800, f/4, 1/25, taken on manual exposure mode, matrix metering, with the light meter at 0. Let's assume that this is the correct exposure.
In the next shot, I activated Auto ISO, then changed the aperture and shutter to f/5.6, 1/50, with ISO initially at 800. ISO automatically adjusted to 2800, showing that Auto ISO will adjust upward as needed.
In the following shot, I changed the aperture and shutter to f/2.8, 1/13 with ISO initially at 800. ISO automatically adjusted to 220, showing that Auto ISO will also adjust downward as needed.
In this shot, I changed the aperture and shutter to f/2.8, 1/6. ISO could not adjust below the base ISO (ISO 200 for the D300), resulting in overexposure (you do get a warning of sorts because the light meter will show an overexposure).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



