Showing posts with label composition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label composition. Show all posts

Friday, November 18, 2011

Winning a Photo Contest

Old Control Tower at LAX

Winning a photo contest both is and isn't a big deal.  It isn't a big deal in the sense that a real artist would care more about expressing his or her idea and less about the audience reaction.  On the other hand, I believe that art is a form of communication that becomes perfected when it is received by another person in a meeting of minds.

I entered the shot above in a photo contest and it was one of the winning entries.  This is the second year in a row when I've had a winning entry in this contest and I thought I'd talk about the approach I used in making this photo.

Monday, September 26, 2011

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Monday, March 14, 2011

Tip: Using a Zoom Lens as a Compositional Aid


I am quite busy this week and behind the schedule for my next article, so until then, here's an extremely useful tip for everyone that I found a while ago on Digital Photography School. I hope you enjoy this article as much as I did.

NOTE: The illustration shown above is taken from Canon's EF Lens Work III, they have very useful material for everyone regardless of the camera/lens brand. I would really suggest you read it, and here is a direct link to the PDF with the illustration shown above.

Monday, January 17, 2011

It's not about you

Snapshot
"Snapshot"

Family photos are by definition personal.  For a viewer who doesn't know the author or subject of the photo, it can be hard to recreate the context that makes the moment special.

One way that a family photo can transcend that barrier is by offering the viewer something beyond the personal aspect of the photo.  That was my objective in the shot above.  The literal subject is the couple and I have no doubt that the particular moment here was a memory worth preserving for them.  However, for anyone who doesn't know them, the moment doesn't hold the same significance.

Although the couple is the literal subject of the photo, they are merely supporting actors for the intended main subjects of the photo - the landscape and the lighting - subjects that are accessible to almost any viewer.

I got the idea for this photo from some wedding photos made by Lito Sy ( http://www.litosy.com/ ), who has won several WPPI awards.  The way I got the shot mirrored my intent.  First, I composed the landscape shot.  When I saw the couple, I tried to anticipate where they might be going.  When they found a spot, I readjusted my composition, this time including them as an element, then took the shot.

Saturday, September 25, 2010

What's the point of having different lenses? Controlling composition with different focal lengths (Basic)

1.  What's the point of having different lenses?  Can't you just move closer or further away?
At first glance, it may seem that having more than one lens is unnecessary.  Shouldn't lenses give us the same appearance as what we see with our eyes? Then we could just walk closer to the subject if we want a close-up view, and walk farther back if we want a wider view. 
However, it's not that simple.  Lenses with different focal lengths have different magnification, field of view, potential perspective, and depth of field.  See below.

2. MAGNIFICATION.
Perhaps the most obvious difference between lenses of different focal lengths is the difference in magnification.  All things being equal (including a constant distance between the camera and the subject), with a wide lens, the subject will look smaller, and with a telephoto lens, the subject will look larger.

On the other hand, if we move closer to the subject, the subject will also look larger than if we were further away, so wouldn't walking closer be the same thing as using telephoto lens?  With respect to the magnification of a single subject with a blank background, it may seem that way.  However, walking closer to the subject doesn't magnify everything uniformly. Closer objects get larger faster than further objects.

Experiment 1: "Magnification" from moving closer.
1. Find two objects of the same length.  Place them apart from each other. 

2. Step back, at least 3 feet away from the near object.  Hold your hand across your face and compare the length of the near object relative to the length of your index finger.  Compare the far object's length to your finger as well.
The near pen looks about 16% of the length from my thumb to the tip of my index finger.  The far pen looks about 13% of the length from my thumb to the tip of my index finger.

3. Without moving your hand, walk forward so that the near pen appears about as long as your finger.  Compare the far pen's length to the length of your finger.
The near pen is about 80% of the length from my thumb to the tip of my finger.  The far pen looks about 16% of the same length.

Result:  At the point when the near pen looked about as long as your finger, the far pen did not look nearly as long as your finger.  Moving closer did magnify both the near pen and far pen but the near pen got magnified much faster. 

Experiment 2: Magnification from using a longer focal length.
To illustrate the difference that a longer focal length makes in terms of magnification, we can setup the same experiment above, this time using a simulated longer focal length.
1. Find two pens of the same length.  Place them around 2 feet apart from each other.


2. Step back, at least 3 feet away from the near pen.  Form a circle with your thumb and index finger.  Place this circle around your eye.  This simulates the view of a camera with a 'normal' (not wide, nor telephoto) lens.  Compare the length of the near pen relative to your circle.  Compare the length of the far pen relative to your circle.

3. Without moving closer, move your circle closer to the two pens.  This simulates the view of a camera with a telephoto lens.  Compare the length of the near pen relative to your circle.  Compare the length of the far pen relative to your circle.

Result: the magnification from a longer lens is uniform.
Conclusion:  moving closer to the subject doesn't "magnify" everything uniformly. Closer objects appear larger faster than further objects. On the other hand, the magnification from a longer lens is uniform.  Therefore, in terms of magnification, moving closer is not a substitute for a longer lens.  Similarly, moving further back is not a substitute for a wider lens.

Compare these shots:
50mm
150mm
In both shots, the subjects stayed at about the same position.  I took the first shot at 50mm.  For the second shot, I moved backward several feet then used 150mm.  The subjects look about the same size in the relation to the frame.  However, the background looks very different -- the statue appears "larger" in the shot with the longer focal length.


See also this related post by mshafik: http://betterfamilyphotos.blogspot.com/2011/03/tip-using-zoom-lens-as-compositional.html


3. FIELD OF VIEW
Another obvious difference between lenses of different focal lengths is the difference in field of view.  Suppose you line up 180 bottles, side-by-side, around you in a semi-circle.  (Don't worry -- this is just a thought experiment... I won't ask you to find 180 bottles :D ) With a telephoto lens (let's say 210mm), you would see only 10 bottles.  With a wide lens (let's say 28mm), you can see around 66 bottles total.  In terms of field of view, a long lens is like looking through a narrow tube.
The question is, if you had a tele lens, could you move back far enough that you would see 66 bottles?  Yes you could.  But your field of view would not change.  Suppose in the semi-circle, when we were still using the wide lens, the leftmost bottle had behind it several feet away in the background a flagpole or something.  That flagpole would be visible in the wide lens shot.  However, if we move back with our tele lens far enough to see 66 bottles, that flagpole would not be visible.
Demo shots:
17mm - 2 pens visible, touching the edge of the image.  Note the chairs visible in the background.
50mm without stepping back - 2 pens not visible:

50mm with step back - 2 pens visible, touching the edge of the image.  Note, however, that the chairs are not visible in the background.

4.  PERSPECTIVE and COMPRESSION.
We saw a bit of perspective in the magnification experiment, where we noted that far objects appear disproportionately smaller than near objects.  The same principle applies within a single object -- the part that is farther appears disproportionately smaller, while the part that is near appears disproportionately larger.  When the subject is near the relative differences between the near parts and far parts are large, thus there is greater distortion.  When the subject is far, the relative differences are small, thus there is less distortion (and the subject appears 'flatter').

17mm:


50mm:


150mm:

How perspective relates to focal length:  actually, focal length itself does not affect perspective.  However, wider lenses generally allow us to be nearer to a subject (which in turn leads to greater perspective distortion), while telephoto lenses allow us to be further from the subject (leading to less perspective distortion).
5. DEPTH OF FIELD
Depth of field is the range of distances that looks sharp.  A narrow depth of field is useful for keeping only a specific range in focus and everything else blurred.  A deep depth of field is useful for making everything appear to be in focus (even though actually, there is only one exact distance that is exactly in focus).  Depth of field is based on the distance from camera to the subject, the aperture used, and the focal length of the lens.  (We'll talk about sensor size later.)
A lens with a longer focal length has a shallower depth of field.  On the other hand, depth of field is also shallower when the camera to subject distance is short, so wouldn't moving closer also give a shallower depth of field?  I tested this. Take a look at these shots:

Shot 1 (tele lens): 150mm, f/2.8.

Shot 2 (normal lens but closer): 50mm, f/2.8.  At a closer distance, the subject looks about the same size as with the tele lens.  The depth of field also appears somewhat similar based on the blurriness of the objects in the background.

With respect to depth of field it appears you may get away with moving back and forth.

6. NORMAL VS. WIDE VS. TELEPHOTO
A normal lens is a lens that has a perspective of about the same as the human eye (taking into account sensor size).  On a full-frame camera, this is about 50mm.  A lens that is wider than field of view of a normal lens is a wide lens.  Longer than that is a telephoto lens.
  
7. WHAT ABOUT CROPPING?
Is there any difference between cropping a wide shot and using a telephoto lens (ignoring the effects of the decreased resolution).  If we crop an image from the middle, then there is no difference in magnification, field of view, and perspective.  With depth of field, there seems to be a difference.  Compare these shots:

50mm:

17mm (from the same distance) cropped:
  
8. WHAT ABOUT SENSOR SIZE?
Caveat: this is a somewhat controversial topic with many points of view from 'experts.'  My rationale is below which I hope helps you to evaluate whether it is right or wrong.

Full-frame DSLRs have the same sensor size as 35mm film.  APS-C sensor DSLRs have a sensor size that is about 2/3 as small as that of a full frame DSLR.  Four-thirds and Micro-Four-Thirds cameras have a sensor half as small as that of a full frame DSLR.  A full-frame lens would focus the same size image on the sensor no matter what the size of the sensor.  However, because a small-sensor camera has a smaller recording surface, then only the middle part of the focused image is being used.  The effect of using a small-sensor camera is the same as if you cropped a photo from a full-frame camera.  This is essentially the same as #7.

If you have a full-frame camera with a 50mm lens, and then you crop the middle part so that it's like the field of view of a 75mm lens on the full-frame camera, the cropped image will look like the image from the same 50mm lens on a 1.5x crop camera in terms of magnification, field of view, and perspective.  As for depth of field, there are some who say that if a full-frame camera is cropped to the same field of view, then the depth of field will be the same as well (see, e.g. statement #3 here http://photo.net/learn/optics/dofdigital/ ).  I thought so too but after the cropping test in #7, I'm not sure that is true.

9.  CHOOSING FOCAL LENGTHS FOR COMPOSITION.
Because of the different characteristics of different focal lengths, they have unique uses for composition. 

Wide lenses are often used to establish a sense of place.  If you buy a ticket to go to Disneyland, you generally want to show in the photo that it was at Disneyland, and not just any random place.  A wide lens captures more of the background and gives the viewer an idea of the location.
Telephoto lenses are useful for de-emphasizing the location or for focusing the attention solely on the subject.  If you are someplace not so special, and there are many objects around that would detract from the photo, using a telephoto lens can help simplify the background.

Because of the differences between lenses of different focal lengths, ideally you should pick the right focal length first then position yourself for the right composition. 

Monday, August 9, 2010

Simple Backgrounds (Basic)



Simplifying the background of a photo often strengthens the photo's composition.  The photo above is a shot of our toddler's art project hanging in my office (taken with a camera phone).  The first time I tried to take the photo, it looked like this:


In my opinion, I thought the composition wasn't so bad.  The shadow from the leaves could perhaps be justified as echoing the chaotic curves of the painting.  But I liked the concept well enough that I thought it was worth strengthening, so I waited the next day to take a similar shot, this time without the shadow of the leaves, to simplify the composition:


I decided to further simplify the composition by removing the larger shadows at the corners, so I waited some more for the shadows to be where I wanted them to be:



In my opinion, the simplification of the background made the composition stronger than either of the previous versions.  This became the final shot (after a little postprocessing).

Recently, I've also tried to be more aware of simple backgrounds and the potential for a stronger composition in photos of our toddler.  It's never easy to control composition with an active toddler but at least choosing the setting can increase the likelihood of a decent photo.

The composition here is flawed because of the cut-off hand (darn!), but this shot illustrates the effect of a simpler background, which in this case also has leading lines.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Beware of Straws and Flowers (Basic)



I've ruined a number of shots by having a drinking straw or a flower seem to poke a subject's face or nose.  It's fairly easy to avoid them when taking a shot of a single person but when there are several people in the shot, it's easy for me to miss the evil drinking straw or flower.  These days I simply keep in mind as a rule of thumb that if there's a straw or flower anywhere nearby, I ought to be extra mindful of straws, flowers or other objects that may be eager to climb into nostrils!

Saturday, October 24, 2009

Comments on first family's photo

Yahoo news reported that the first family's first official photo was released. Here's the photo, taken by Annie Leibovitz. Of course the photo looks good and I like the expressions on their beautiful faces, but from a purely technical point of view, I'm a bit surprised that the lighting looks so simple and frankly underwhelming to me.  Maybe it's "deceptively simple" and too subtle for me. It seems possible to duplicate the lighting by simply bouncing the flash behind and camera right. Or by a large umbrella or softbox. From the catchlight on the original size photo, I'm guessing Annie used a softbox. I can't tell whether a fill light was used.  Doesn't seem like it. I'm wondering whether Annie used a hair light, because the first lady's hair has a shine, but the shine could have come from the key.

From the background it looks like ambient was killed (intentionally I assume).  Looking at the exif, I'm kinda puzzled too. It says:
  • Canon 1Ds MkIII
  • f/8, 1/125, ISO 400, 0 EV.
If I wanted to take this same shot, I would have instead gone to max sync speed (1/250 for the 1Ds MkIII)  and used a lower ISO.  Because there's no ambient anyway, the faster shutter and lower ISO wouldn't change the lighting of the shot.  The lower ISO would have less noise (though I concede that the 1Ds probably has negligible noise even at ISO 400) and the fast shutter would minimize blur from subject movement (though I am guessing that with virtually no ambient, the light was all flash, thus shutter speed was effectively the duration of the flash, i.e. 1/1000 or faster).  On the other hand, if Annie bounced the flash and didn't use a softbox, I can understand the use of ISO 400.  I doubt she did though, because bouncing can be more unpredictable for white balance, and there may be unintended reflections.

If I were to take my own version of this shot, I would have allowed more ambient light, because I think the darkness in the rooms in the background seems unnatural and to me off-putting. Or with Annie's unlimited resources, I would have placed another flash in the rooms at the back to light them up. The light from the flash also looks a bit cold. Perhaps it needs a gel. I might have also placed a gold reflector in front of them and bounced a bit of flash into it to add even more sparkle and warmth to their eyes.  In terms of composition, I think I would tried a very slightly lower height to decrease the negative space on top. I also think I would have picked a room with a less somber color (given the current economy).  In terms of choice of equipment, I believe the leader of the free world and his family deserve a shot from a medium format camera (digital or otherwise) for posterity.

Thursday, October 22, 2009

Scan the Frame

Summary: I improved the composition of my shots by taking a moment to scan the frame.

The Issue:
Old habits die hard.  When composing a shot, I usually frame the shot, move the focus point to the point of interest where I want to focus (usually the eyes), half-press the shutter then take the shot.  Although I do think about the background and the rest of the picture, I tend to do so only while thinking of the shot, before I look through the viewfinder.  The problem with that process is that I'm too focused on the point of interest and not sufficiently mindful about the rest of the picture when taking the shot.  The result is that sometimes I inadvertently leave out important elements of the picture.

For example, this shot would have looked better with our toddler's hands visible in the frame.


Sometimes, I can crop to disguise the error. Other times, I can't, or I would have to crop very tightly.

The Solution:
Awareness of the problems created by my old habits led me to take a second to scan the frame just before taking the shot.  It's not easy to resist the temptation to simply take the shot when our toddler is running around and suddenly has a great expression on his face.  But taking a moment to scan the frame improved the composition of my shots and helped me to ensure that all important elements are there.



I'm also considering getting a wider-angle zoom like the Tamron 17-50 VC if I can find a way to fit it into our budget. :)